If you are to choose a captain for yourself / your crew, which of the following types of people will you favor:
1) An ability user - any characters with DF, e.g. Whitebeard or Akainu, disregarding marine or pirate side
2) A haki monster - characters without DFP who heavily dependent on haki, the likes of Rayleigh, Shanks, Garp, Vergo etc
3) A third kind, skill dependent user - characters without DFP and not relying solely on haki (may or may not have high level of haki), characters like Mihawk, Zoro, Sanji. Hell Caroline could also make into this kind.
After choosing your captain type, then who do you choose as your captain. Could be any canon characters from OP who fits into the description that you have selected above.
Please limit to those characters with CONFIRMED facts, stuffs like Doflamingo is an ability user is still NOT a hard fact yet despite all the allusions.
Personally I prefer the 3rd kind and I'd like Mihawk as my captain.
A side poll: With the conclusion of FI arc (both manga - a long time ago - and anime - recently), how do you rate the arc?