One Piece Wiki
Register
Tag: sourceedit
Tag: rte-source
(9 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 9: Line 9:
 
==Anime and Manga Differences==
 
==Anime and Manga Differences==
 
===Takoyaki===
 
===Takoyaki===
In the anime when Brook first joined the Straw Hats for dinner, the dinner that was being served was a banquet of various octopus-based cuisine, whereas in the manga the dinner was unspecified.
+
In the anime, when Brook first joined the Straw Hats for dinner, the dinner that was being served was a banquet of varied octopus-based cuisine, among which were Takoyaki balls made by Sanji.{{qref|ep=338|Brook is seen enjoying a dinner which includes Takoyaki, with the Straw Hats on the Thousand Sunny.}}
   
While this scene does not differ from the manga much due to it being unspecified in the manga, it however somewhat contradicts what is stated in the manga in a later scene. Among the dishes being served in the anime are some Takoyaki balls made by Sanji. Though Brook is not seen eating them, it may be implied that he also ate them among other things.{{qref|ep=338|Brook is seen enjoying a dinner which includes Takoyaki, with the Straw Hats on the Thousand Sunny.}}
+
While this scene does not differ from the manga much due to the dinner's food not being specified in the latter, it does provide a possible contradiction to what is stated in the manga in a later scene. Namely, when Brook and the rest of the Straw Hats enjoy some Takoyaki as a reward for saving [[Hatchan]], Brook states that it was the first time he enjoyed Takoyaki.{{qref|chap=496|Brook states it is the first time he eating Takoyaki when he dines at the Takoyaki 8 with the rest of the crew.}} However, it is only a possible contradiction, as Brook is not seen partaking of Sanji's Takoyaki.
 
This contradicts what happens later when Brook and rest of the Straw Hats enjoy some Takoyaki as a reward for saving [[Hatchan]]. The later manga scene has Brook stating that it was the first time he enjoyed Takoyaki thus making the contradiction.{{qref|chap=496|Brook states it is the first time he eating Takoyaki when he dines at the Takoyaki 8 with the rest of the crew.}}
 
   
 
===Duels with Ryuma===
 
===Duels with Ryuma===
Line 57: Line 55:
 
*Brook, Roronoa Zoro and Kin'emon vs. G-5 Marines
 
*Brook, Roronoa Zoro and Kin'emon vs. G-5 Marines
 
*Brook, Kin'emon, Nami, Usopp, and Nico Robin vs. [[Vegapunk|Vegapunk's]] Dragon
 
*Brook, Kin'emon, Nami, Usopp, and Nico Robin vs. [[Vegapunk|Vegapunk's]] Dragon
*Brook, Nami, Tony Tony Chopper and [[Momonosuke]] vs. [[Jora]]
+
*Brook,Nami,Tony Tony Chopper and Momonosuke vs. [[Jora]]
 
*Brook vs. Jora
 
*Brook vs. Jora
  +
*Brook and Sanji vs. [[Sheepshead]]
 
</div>}}
 
</div>}}
   
Line 67: Line 66:
 
*Brook and Sanji vs. [[Boxer Penguin]], [[Kill Rabi]], [[Big Tree]], and other animals ''(offscreen)''
 
*Brook and Sanji vs. [[Boxer Penguin]], [[Kill Rabi]], [[Big Tree]], and other animals ''(offscreen)''
 
*Brook, Nami, Usopp, Tony Tony Chopper and Robin vs. [[Neo Marines]]
 
*Brook, Nami, Usopp, Tony Tony Chopper and Robin vs. [[Neo Marines]]
*Brook,Nami,Chopper and Momonosuke vs. Jora
+
*Brook,Nami and Momonosuke vs. Jora
   
 
==Translation and Dub Issues==
 
==Translation and Dub Issues==
Line 118: Line 117:
 
* It is possible a partial inspiration for Brook's backstory came from the poem (and song by the British metal band Iron Maiden) "[[Wikipedia:The Rime of the Ancient_Mariner|The Rime of the Ancient Mariner]]", by Samuel Taylor Coleridge. It involves a mariner and his crew who are led out of the fog of Antarctica by an albatross, but the mariner shoots it down and curses his crew into calm waters. Through a game of dice, Death claims the lives of all his crew, but Life-in-Death claims the mariner, who is cursed to a fate worse than death by remaining on the bleak, foggy ship alongside his dead crew for ages, forced to relive all their deaths through the looks in their eyes, until finally acknowledging the beauty of life and its creatures, and released from drifting through the fog, ecstatically jumping for joy when he sees the first living people to approach and take him away, to tell his tale of warning, now a sadder but wiser man.
 
* It is possible a partial inspiration for Brook's backstory came from the poem (and song by the British metal band Iron Maiden) "[[Wikipedia:The Rime of the Ancient_Mariner|The Rime of the Ancient Mariner]]", by Samuel Taylor Coleridge. It involves a mariner and his crew who are led out of the fog of Antarctica by an albatross, but the mariner shoots it down and curses his crew into calm waters. Through a game of dice, Death claims the lives of all his crew, but Life-in-Death claims the mariner, who is cursed to a fate worse than death by remaining on the bleak, foggy ship alongside his dead crew for ages, forced to relive all their deaths through the looks in their eyes, until finally acknowledging the beauty of life and its creatures, and released from drifting through the fog, ecstatically jumping for joy when he sees the first living people to approach and take him away, to tell his tale of warning, now a sadder but wiser man.
 
* He is the second skeleton pirate shown in One Piece. The first was the non-canonical [[Captain (Marine Rank)|Captain]] [[Joke]].
 
* He is the second skeleton pirate shown in One Piece. The first was the non-canonical [[Captain (Marine Rank)|Captain]] [[Joke]].
* In the 4th Japanese [[Popularity Polls|Fan Poll]], he came out as the ninth most popular character. Coincidentally, he is also the ninth member to join the Straw Hats, counting Luffy. In the 5th poll, he ranked nineteenth.
+
* In the 4th Japanese [[Popularity Polls|Fan Poll]], he came out as the ninth most popular character. Coincidentally, he is also the ninth member to join the Straw Hats, counting Luffy. In the 5th poll, he ranked nineteenth.
 
* Brook's outfit in [[One Piece Film: Strong World]] is almost identical to the outfit worn by the young Micheal Jackson in a film-clip performed by the Jackson Five.
 
* Brook's outfit in [[One Piece Film: Strong World]] is almost identical to the outfit worn by the young Micheal Jackson in a film-clip performed by the Jackson Five.
 
* In [[Episode 509]], when Brook starts playing the composition to raise the people's spirits, the music played on his violin is the same piece played by [[Butler]], "The song of the horn eaters", from the third movie. The music, however, was originally used to make animals start rampaging, rather than raise people's spirits.
 
* In [[Episode 509]], when Brook starts playing the composition to raise the people's spirits, the music played on his violin is the same piece played by [[Butler]], "The song of the horn eaters", from the third movie. The music, however, was originally used to make animals start rampaging, rather than raise people's spirits.
 
* Brook's model sheets in TOEI are named "Blook".
 
* Brook's model sheets in TOEI are named "Blook".
 
* In [[One Piece Blue Deep: Characters World]], Brook's post-timeskip height is said to be 277cm,{{qref|data=blue deep|page=152|Brook's data after the timeskip.}} 11cm taller than his pre-timeskip height. This appears to contradict what he said during his fight with Ryuma; that it was important for him to protect his afro because his body had stopped growing.{{qref|chap=458|ep=352|Brook says his body has stopped growing.}}
 
* In [[One Piece Blue Deep: Characters World]], Brook's post-timeskip height is said to be 277cm,{{qref|data=blue deep|page=152|Brook's data after the timeskip.}} 11cm taller than his pre-timeskip height. This appears to contradict what he said during his fight with Ryuma; that it was important for him to protect his afro because his body had stopped growing.{{qref|chap=458|ep=352|Brook says his body has stopped growing.}}
  +
* Brook is the only Straw Hat to have never ridden aboard the Going Merry.
 
=== SBS-Based Trivia===
 
=== SBS-Based Trivia===
 
* Brook's birthday, April 3, comes from his Devil Fruit's name since 4-3 can be derived from yo-mi.{{qref|name="Brook birthday"}}
 
* Brook's birthday, April 3, comes from his Devil Fruit's name since 4-3 can be derived from yo-mi.{{qref|name="Brook birthday"}}
Line 136: Line 136:
 
* Brook bathes once a week.{{qref|sbs=67|page=182|fan question: How often do the Straw Hats bathe?}}
 
* Brook bathes once a week.{{qref|sbs=67|page=182|fan question: How often do the Straw Hats bathe?}}
 
* Brook's least favorite food is lemons.{{qref|sbs=73|page=144|fan question: Please tell me each crew member's most disliked food!}}
 
* Brook's least favorite food is lemons.{{qref|sbs=73|page=144|fan question: Please tell me each crew member's most disliked food!}}
  +
* Brook typically sleeps at 12:00 A.M. and wakes up at 5:00 A.M.{{qref|sbs=74|page=126|fan question: I would like to know the Straw Hats' bed times and wake up times!}}
  +
* Brook would work as a detective if he weren't a pirate.{{qref|sbs=76|page=42|fan question: If the Straw Hats never became pirates, what would their careers of choice be?}}
   
 
==References==
 
==References==

Revision as of 00:47, 31 July 2015

Template:Brook Infobox

Early One Piece

Early Brook

Early concept of Brook from One Piece Green.

In One Piece Green: Secret Pieces was revealed an early concept of Brook.

The concept of Brook, a skeleton musician, had already been thought up by Oda the first time he drew Laboon. Brook's overall design however was not finalized back then but the basic idea was kept for a long time until Brook was finally revealed.[1]

Anime and Manga Differences

Takoyaki

In the anime, when Brook first joined the Straw Hats for dinner, the dinner that was being served was a banquet of varied octopus-based cuisine, among which were Takoyaki balls made by Sanji.[2]

While this scene does not differ from the manga much due to the dinner's food not being specified in the latter, it does provide a possible contradiction to what is stated in the manga in a later scene. Namely, when Brook and the rest of the Straw Hats enjoy some Takoyaki as a reward for saving Hatchan, Brook states that it was the first time he enjoyed Takoyaki.[3] However, it is only a possible contradiction, as Brook is not seen partaking of Sanji's Takoyaki.

Duels with Ryuma

The flashback of the first duel between Brook and Ryuma is handled differently in the manga and anime versions:

Skull shatter
The end of the duel (manga version).
File:End of Brook vs. Ryuma Anime.png
The end of the duel (anime version).

Originally in the manga, the duel against Ryuma is so fierce that pieces of Brook's bones are broken and fly off in the process as he takes hits from the zombie.[4] While the duel is much longer with more moves portrayed in the anime, it is noticeably less violent by the fact that though Brook is attacked by Ryuma, there is only one instance where a few pieces of bone are broken off by the attacks.[5]

The duel ultimately ends violently with Ryuma stabbing his sword through Brook's skull and creating a huge crack which fortunately "healed" over time. The duel in the anime ends considerably much different with Ryuma threatening to stab Brook's skull instead of stabbing through it like in manga.

While the anime portrayed the fight in the flashback less violently, it however portrayed the rematch between the two with the same intensity as in the manga. It showed scenes wherein Brook was stabbed by Ryuma with normally fatal but otherwise bone cracking strikes.[6]

Color Scheme

In Gear Spirit, Brook is presented with a different color scheme than the one depicted in both the manga and anime. The color of the collar of his coat is gray while the ribbon and the frills coming out of his coat are purple. In some artwork within the game, Brook's nose socket is uncolored. The outer covering of Brook's cane sword is also colored red in the game. This color scheme is so because the game was developed before an official color scheme from the manga was presented.[7]

Although Brook's cane has normally been portrayed in various media as purple (after his official color scheme is revealed), there is an exception on the cover of volume 50, where it is unexpectedly light blue. The mistake seems to be that the colors between Brook's ribbon and cane have been switched, because on the same cover the ribbon is purple instead of its normal blue.[8]

Brook's glasses that he gets after the timeskip are purple in the manga. In the anime, they are pink.

Major Battles

Filler and Movie Battles

Translation and Dub Issues

In the 4Kids English dub adaption of the anime, the sequence in which the Straw Hats encountered Laboon was cut for various reasons. Due to this, aside from parts of the story being changed in order to coincide with the cut, a plot hole was created in the 4Kids version of the anime concerning an integral part of Brook's character, namely Brook's relationship with the whale. Though the 4Kids dub stopped at the start of the Jaya Arc, the plot hole created still stands.

Merchandise

Video Games

Playable Appearances

Support Appearances

Anime and Manga Influences

Brook, like the rest of various characters introduced in the Thriller Bark arc, is based on certain elements taken from The Nightmare Before Christmas, The Addams Family, and various zombie movies.[9]

Other Appearances

Other Media

Brook Premiere Show

Brook as he appears in the show.



Trivia

File:Brook's Personal Jolly Roger Pre Timeskip.png
Brook's personal jolly roger.
File:Brook Timeskip Jolly Roger.png
Brook's post timeskip jolly roger.
  • Like other members of the Straw Hat crew, Brook has his own personal jolly roger: it is a skull without a jaw with Brook's trademark afro, a top hat, and a cane in place of the cross bone mark. His jolly roger is also shown on his travel mug and tea cup. His jolly roger was seen worn by one of fans.
    • Oda has also revealed a post-timeskip jolly roger. The design for this one includes a full skull and an afro, with his new glasses and hat. His afro and skull is encircled by bones with his single guitar as his cross-bones in the background.
  • Brook is the oldest member of the Straw Hats, being 38 (dying 2 years after leaving Laboon, then spending a year seeking his body) at the time of his death and 88 years old when he meets the crew (most likely a reference to the number of keys on a piano).
  • He is the tallest member of the Straw Hats, being 277cm (9'1) as he is even taller than Franky who is over seven feet tall.
  • Brook is currently the only member of the Straw Hat crew that was a pirate captain of his own seafaring pirate crew. 
  • Brook's height before the timeskip, 8'8" could be related to the usual number of keys on a piano, 88.
  • Brook Smoking in Movie 10

    Brook smoking in movie 10.

    In Strong World, Brook was seen smoking. However, this is a non-canon source and he was never seen smoking in the canon series.
  • Before Brook fulfilled the position of musician, there was a running gag of the need for the position to be filled that was always being brought up by Luffy during important meetings with his crew on who should join next. Whenever the Straw Hats hold a serious meeting about a situation they are in that might require the addition of a new crew member with skills to aid in that situation, or anything similar like that, Luffy would always bring up the need of getting a musician. His reasoning is that pirates love to sing and a musician is essential to a pirate crew. Luffy's request however would always be turned down by his crew for more practical solutions to the situation.
  • The idea of a skeleton musician was first conceived by Oda in the year 2000.
  • In Chapter 488 the first digit of his bounty is a 2. This was a mistake by Oda that was later corrected.
  • Since the introduction of Brook's bounty, there was speculation of whether his Beli33,000,000 bounty was active or not. In Chapter 600, Marines declared that his bounty was still active, thus ending the speculation.
  • Brook's unique laugh of "Yoho" is a stereotypical pirate line commonly found in various pirate related pop culture. It originates from “Dead Man's Chest”, the sea shanty from the book Treasure Island.
  • It is possible a partial inspiration for Brook's backstory came from the poem (and song by the British metal band Iron Maiden) "The Rime of the Ancient Mariner", by Samuel Taylor Coleridge. It involves a mariner and his crew who are led out of the fog of Antarctica by an albatross, but the mariner shoots it down and curses his crew into calm waters. Through a game of dice, Death claims the lives of all his crew, but Life-in-Death claims the mariner, who is cursed to a fate worse than death by remaining on the bleak, foggy ship alongside his dead crew for ages, forced to relive all their deaths through the looks in their eyes, until finally acknowledging the beauty of life and its creatures, and released from drifting through the fog, ecstatically jumping for joy when he sees the first living people to approach and take him away, to tell his tale of warning, now a sadder but wiser man.
  • He is the second skeleton pirate shown in One Piece. The first was the non-canonical Captain Joke.
  • In the 4th Japanese Fan Poll, he came out as the ninth most popular character. Coincidentally, he is also the ninth member to join the Straw Hats, counting Luffy. In the 5th poll, he ranked nineteenth.
  • Brook's outfit in One Piece Film: Strong World is almost identical to the outfit worn by the young Micheal Jackson in a film-clip performed by the Jackson Five.
  • In Episode 509, when Brook starts playing the composition to raise the people's spirits, the music played on his violin is the same piece played by Butler, "The song of the horn eaters", from the third movie. The music, however, was originally used to make animals start rampaging, rather than raise people's spirits.
  • Brook's model sheets in TOEI are named "Blook".
  • In One Piece Blue Deep: Characters World, Brook's post-timeskip height is said to be 277cm,[10] 11cm taller than his pre-timeskip height. This appears to contradict what he said during his fight with Ryuma; that it was important for him to protect his afro because his body had stopped growing.[11]
  • Brook is the only Straw Hat to have never ridden aboard the Going Merry.

SBS-Based Trivia

  • Brook's birthday, April 3, comes from his Devil Fruit's name since 4-3 can be derived from yo-mi.[12]
  • According to Oda, Brook most resembles a horse.[13]
    • However, he wears swallow-based attire, and he has his Soul King attire stolen by his giraffe skeleton counterpart on the cover of Chapter 651.
  • He is identified by the colors black and white.[13]
  • He smells of tea.[13]
  • His favorite type of island is a spring island during the fall.[13]
  • If the Straw Hats were a family, Brook would be the grandfather.[13]
  • Brook would be Austrian in the real world.[14]
  • When asked which flower Brook resembles the most, Robin's voice actress replied he most resembles a rose.[15]
  • Brook's blood type was X (the same as Nami's and Chopper's) when he was alive.[16]
  • Brook bathes once a week.[17]
  • Brook's least favorite food is lemons.[18]
  • Brook typically sleeps at 12:00 A.M. and wakes up at 5:00 A.M.[19]
  • Brook would work as a detective if he weren't a pirate.[20]

References

  1. Interview with Oda — Oda explains that he had Brook already in mind when he first drew Laboon.
  2. One Piece Anime — Episode 338, Brook is seen enjoying a dinner which includes Takoyaki, with the Straw Hats on the Thousand Sunny.
  3. One Piece Manga — Vol. 51 Chapter 496, Brook states it is the first time he eating Takoyaki when he dines at the Takoyaki 8 with the rest of the crew.
  4. One Piece Manga — Vol. 47 Chapter 458, the flashback in the manga portrays a violent duel wherein pieces of Brook's bones are broken off.
  5. One Piece Anime — Episode 352, the flashback in the anime portrays a longer but less violent duel between Brook and Ryuma.
  6. One Piece Anime — Episode 354, the anime shows scenes where Brook is stabbed violently while fighting Ryuma.
  7. One Piece: Gear Spirit — Brook is shown with a color scheme different than the manga and anime.
  8. One Piece Manga — Vol. 50, the colors of Brook's ribbon and cane are switched.
  9. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 51 (p. 186), fan question: Is Thriller Bark inspired by The Addams Family and The Nightmare Before Christmas? I love the atmosphere.
  10. One Piece Blue Deep: Characters World (p. 152), Brook's data after the timeskip.
  11. One Piece Manga and Anime — Vol. 47 Chapter 458 and Episode 352, Brook says his body has stopped growing.
  12. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; no text was provided for refs named Brook birthday
  13. 13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 50 (p. 86), fan question: what are the personal info for the Straw Hats who weren't around when certain questions were asked about the group?
  14. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 56 (p. 144), fan question: If the Straw Hats were real, what nationality would they be from?
  15. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 60 (p. 206), fan question: Which flower would suit each of the Straw Hats?
  16. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 66 (p. 162), fan question: What is each of the Straw Hats blood type?
  17. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 67 (p. 182), fan question: How often do the Straw Hats bathe?
  18. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 73 (p. 144), fan question: Please tell me each crew member's most disliked food!
  19. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 74 (p. 126), fan question: I would like to know the Straw Hats' bed times and wake up times!
  20. SBS One Piece Manga — Vol. 76 (p. 42), fan question: If the Straw Hats never became pirates, what would their careers of choice be?